Buttman Review 2026: Anal Porn Site from Evil Angel

John Stagliano's own gonzo channel, shot by the director whose nickname became the brand.

Published
⚠ No longer updated
Verified November 10, 2026 · last scene Jul 2023
Buttman Anal preview

Buttman in numbers

7.2 / 10GoodHow we score →
What we foundPoints
Content Volume945 videos · 300 models
15.0/15
Brand Popularity
8.4/15
Video Quality4K, Daily (300GB per terms 9.1) downloads
12.7/15
Update Frequencylast Jul 28
4.7/10
Value for Moneyfrom $9.95/mo · paid yearly
9.0/10
Features & UXstreaming, downloads, mobile
7.7/10
Bonus Content
13.8/25
Crypto payments acceptedbonus+1
📝

Full Review

By Clark Usman, Adult Site Analyst

Nothing new has gone up here since July 28, 2023, so what you buy is a closed archive of 945 scenes going back to 2000. It's still big for anal, 4.5 times the niche median.

I'd only take the year plan, and only for the archive or for the wider lineup the login opens. The trial can't download, and refunds stop once you've logged in.

John Stagliano's own channel, silent since July 2023

The newest scene on the site is dated July 28, 2023, and I found nothing added after it.

The tour calls this the official site of John Stagliano, the director known as Buttman, and credits him with creating the studio it belongs to. It's anal gonzo from the rough end of the shelf. The tour and checkout pages name gapes and extreme insertions as selling points, and the oldest scene in the catalog is dated February 22, 2000.

So you're buying an archive, and I'd price it that way. The tour banner still says new videos every week. On this site, that hasn't been true for over three years.

A library 4.5 times the anal niche median

Against the 51 anal sites we track, this library ranks #6 by size, 4.5 times the niche median.

That's why Content Volume sits at the top of our scale here. You get 945 scenes, with over 350 photo sets on top.

The output was never steady. 2010 is the busiest year on record with 292 scenes, and the catalog chart shows how thin the years after it got.

  • Videos: the tour banner says 19,000+ exclusive videos, I counted 945 on this site itself.
  • Updates: the tour says new videos every week, the last 12 months here had 0 scenes.

98 performers seen on no other site

Of the 300 performers, 98 (32.7% of the cast) appear on no other site we've parsed.

The regulars are names anal fans will know. Sheena Shaw has the most scenes, ahead of Jada Stevens, Roxy Raye and Kelly Divine, with Brooklyn Lee close behind.

Most names don't come back. 163 performers (54.3%) shot exactly once, while 83 have five scenes or more.

4K on the banner, 1080p HD in the member benefits

The tour can't decide on resolution: its banner says 4K, while the member benefits list on the same page says full 1080p HD.

Our records list 4K as the top resolution, and Video Quality rates well on our scale. I didn't play a file, though, so I can't tell you how much of the library carries it.

Scenes average 33 minutes, which is proper gonzo length. All three paid plans list unlimited streaming and unlimited downloads on the join page, and the tour promises DRM-free downloading. I'm taking that on the site's word.

Cancel 48 hours early or pay for another term

Getting out takes some planning: the terms want your cancellation in at least 48 hours before each renewal.

I didn't log in, so I can't speak for search or the member player. The tour is easy to read, with every section in one top bar. At a 390-pixel phone width it didn't scroll sideways, though 20 of its 48 tap targets came out tiny.

Checkout runs through Epoch, though the site's footer sends billing questions and cancellations to Segpay. The terms say you stay liable for fees until 48 hours after Client Relations receives and acknowledges your cancellation. Don't leave it to the last day, and keep the acknowledgment.

If the fee changes and you don't cancel within 30 days, the terms count that as agreement.

12.6 cents a scene on the year plan

The year plan is the only one I'd buy: $119.40 works out to 12.6 cents a scene in this library.

Here's what the same 12 months costs on each plan if you keep renewing:

  • Month to month: 12 payments of $29.95, $359.40 in all.
  • 3 Months: four payments of $59.85, $239.40 in all.
  • 1 Year: one payment of $119.40.

Monthly makes no sense here. On a catalog that won't grow, you'd pay $240 more for the same scenes. You can pay by card, US gift card or crypto, but not PayPal, and the add-on box at checkout wasn't pre-ticked.

The join page on November 10, 2026: the $2.95 trial and three paid plans.
The join page on November 10, 2026: the $2.95 trial and three paid plans.

Other reviewers rate this site higher than we do. The gap is updates: we mark a site down hard when it stops, and this one stopped in 2023. Value for Money still comes out strong for us on the year price. If old Stagliano anal is what you're after, I think that's a fair deal.

Over 80 sites open with the same login

The login opens the whole Evil Angel lineup, over 80 sites in our records, and that's where the fresh scenes are.

The site's own pages can't agree on the number. The checkout lists 25 director sites, the tour says over 40, and our records hold over 80.

Rocco Siffredi, Jonni Darkko XXX and Transsexual Angel post several times a week, and Pansexual X added a scene on October 24, 2026.

Bonus Content still lands only in the middle of our scale. Not every included site is alive. Latex Playtime and John Leslie, for two, show as abandoned in our records. If the rough style is the draw, our list of gonzo porn sites has more that still shoot.

⚖️

Pros & Cons

✅ Pros
  • ✓The library ranks #6 by size among the 51 anal sites we track.
  • ✓98 performers in the cast appear on no other site we've parsed.
  • ✓Scenes average 33 minutes, long enough to watch one start to finish.
  • ✓The year plan costs $119.40, which is 12.6 cents a scene.
  • ✓All three paid plans list unlimited downloads on the join page.
  • ✓The login opens over 80 sites, several still posting every week.
❌ Cons
  • ✗No new scene since July 28, 2023, and 0 in the last 12 months.
  • ✗The trial can't download anything and rolls straight into the monthly rate.
  • ✗Refunds end once the login has been used, and a partial month earns nothing back.
  • ✗163 performers (54.3%) shot exactly once and never came back.
  • ✗The tour claims both 4K and 1080p HD on the same page.

Best for You want John Stagliano's anal gonzo back catalog and don't mind that it's closed.

Skip if You join a site for new scenes every week and won't touch the rest of the lineup.

🎬

Scene catalog

Site-specific data · parsed by FapIndex · numbers checked by Dana Reissner
Nothing new since Jul 2023. These are the final uploads before the catalog went quiet.
Scenes
945
Per month
0
last 12 mo
Avg length
33 min
First scene
Feb 2000
Last scene
Jul 2023

Scenes released per month

Feb 2000 → Jul 2023 · peak 237/mo
2370200020012002200320042005200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017201820192020202120222023

Smoothed 3-month average. Gaps = months with zero releases.

⏸
Catalog frozen: no new scenes since Jul 2023
0 scenes in the last 12 months · the archive of 945 scenes stays available

Top content tags

Share of scenes carrying each tag.

  • straight porn
    98%
  • straight
    95%
  • hd porn
    56%
  • natural tits
    47%
  • brunette
    46%
  • toys
    40%
  • college
    39%
  • pornstar
    39%
  • blonde
    36%
  • anal
    34%

What kind of content this is

Share of scenes containing each act or format. Scenes can carry several at once.

  • Anal
    35%
  • Hardcore B/G
    28%
  • POV
    26%
  • BDSM & fetish
    25%
  • Solo & masturbation
    21%
  • Cumshot finishes
    20%
  • Lesbian
    13%
  • Threesomes & group
    12%
  • Squirting
    4%
  • Interracial
    4%
⚡ Stats are computed from Buttman’s actual scene catalog, parsed and counted by FapIndex · crawl of Nov 2026.
👥

The cast

Who performs on Buttman

Top names on Buttman

The performers who carry this catalog, ranked by how much of it they shot · names link to their profile bios

SSSheena Shaw70 scenes
shot here in 2012-2023
JSJada Stevens58 scenes
shot here in 2012-2015
RRRoxy Raye47 scenes
Roxy Raye
shot here in 2012-2020
KDKelly Divine46 scenes
shot here in 2010-2015
BLBrooklyn Lee43 scenes
shot here in 2011-2020
Performers
300
New faces
0
last 12 mo
Typical age
27
at filming
Come back
46%
2+ scenes

Performer age niches

Where the cast falls on the standard industry age niches · typical performer is around 27.

Teens
18-22
Adults
23-29
MILFs
30-44
Mature
45-54
Granny
55+

How often performers come back

Out of 300 performers in this catalog, how many were booked more than once.

46%came back
  • Regulars, 5 or more scenes83 · 28%
  • Came back, 2 to 4 scenes54 · 18%
  • One-time only, single scene163 · 54%
⚡ Stats are computed from Buttman’s actual scene catalog, parsed and counted by FapIndex · crawl of Nov 2026.
💰

Membership Plans

3-Day Trial
$2.95
Rebills at $29.95
Try It
Monthly
$29.95
Recurring
Select Plan
3 Months
$59.85
= $19.95/mo
Recurring
Select Plan
Best Value
1 Year
$119.40
= $9.95/mo
Recurring
Join Now →
🖼️

Content Samples

⚙️

Technical Specs

✓ Yes
Streaming
✓ Daily (300GB per terms 9.1)
Downloads
✓ Optimized
Mobile
4K
Max Quality
🎬 945 videos📷 379 photo galleriesmix: 71% video / 29% photo
🌐

Evil Angel Network

Access all sites via Evil Angel membership

Evil Angel Review →

Join Evil Angel, get all 83+ sites including Buttman for one price.

from $10.95/mo
$2.95
3-Day Trial
$39.95
Monthly
$29.95
Monthly

Verdict

Buttman is a closed archive with a large cast, and 98 of its performers turn up nowhere else we've looked. Take the year plan if this style is what you want, and treat the wider lineup as the fresh part. If you need a site that's still shooting, this isn't it.

Alternatives to Buttman

❓

FAQ

Is Buttman still adding scenes in 2026?

No. The newest scene is dated July 28, 2023, and the 12 months before I checked on November 10, 2026 had none. The other sites on the same login still post, so new material comes from them.

What do the plans cost, and which ones can download?

The 3-day trial is $2.95 with limited streaming and no downloads, then $29.95 every 30 days. The paid plans all list unlimited streaming and downloads: $29.95 a month, $59.85 for 3 months, and $119.40 for a year ($9.95 a month).

Can I get money back if I joined and barely watched?

No. The refund policy says fees aren't refundable once the login details have been used, and there's nothing back for a partial month. The terms want your cancellation in at least 48 hours before renewal.

Does the login include the rest of Evil Angel?

Yes. Our records list over 80 included sites, among them Rocco Siffredi and Jonni Darkko XXX. The site's own pages say 25 in one place and over 40 in another.

Is a year worth it when the site no longer updates?

For the archive alone, yes, if you want Stagliano's anal gonzo: the year comes to 12.6 cents a scene. For fresh scenes you're really paying for the rest of the lineup, and some of it has stopped too.

🛡️

Billing & Safety

ProcessorEpoch
Payment
Credit CardApple PayGift CardCrypto
Cross-sellsYes
📋

Quick Facts

Videos945
Models300
Max Quality4K
UpdatesStopped
Site TypeNetwork Member
NetworkEvil Angel
Bonus Sites83+
Mobile✓ Yes
DownloadsDaily (300GB per terms 9.1)
Streaming✓ Yes
Last UpdateJul 2023
Affiliate Program:Fame Dollars

Review log

what changed since we published
  1. Score 7.0 to 7.2: features & UX +0.8; update frequency +0.5; bonus: Crypto payments accepted
  2. Score 6.2 to 7.0: we updated our scoring method; now rated Good
  3. First published
🏷️

Tags

Clark Usman
Clark Usman
Adult Site Analyst · FapIndex
Published Apr 2026
Updated Nov 2026

Clark has spent years reviewing adult membership sites, comparing content libraries, pricing structures and video quality so you do not have to. Started as a personal spreadsheet of tested memberships in 2008, which is what FapIndex grew out of. Writes every review on this site and signs off on the score before it goes live.

Dana Reissner

Numbers checked by Dana Reissner, Data & Pricing Fact-checker

FapIndex contains affiliate links. When you join through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our automated scoring, all ratings are calculated from objective site data.

Buttman
7.2/10
Visit Site →